No. 461
Crime, Eccentricity, and the Sporting Life in 19th Century America.
February 18, 2020

Boss Cox.

October 17, 2011
...
...

(Thanks to Henry-Clement Sanson for the guest post. The former executioner — the last of his illustrious dynasty comprising six generations of bourreaux — was the grandson of that dread figure of the Paris Terror, Charles Henri Sanson. Henry-Clement’s Memoirs of the Sansons: From Private Notes and Documents (1688-1847) describes some famous or infamous executions […]
More...
Executed Today - 2/17/2020

`
"Denver's Oldest Bar" matchbook cover outside cover - A (Click image to enlarge) new addition to my collection A matchbook cover from "Denver’s Oldest Bar" is a new acquisition to my private Soapy Smith collection. Though it is a "modern" item from the 1960s-70s, it has a direct link to Soapy Smith. "Denver’s Oldest Bar" was once controlled by Soapy, under the name, "Tivoli Club,
More...
Soapy Smith's Soap Box - 2/7/2020

"Boston Globe," August 19, 1905, via Newspapers.com The true-crime writer F. Tennyson Jesse suggested that not only are some people "born murderers," others are "born murderees." It is when these two types of people happen to find each other that you get A Situation. It is an interesting theory, but one that tends to fall apart once you study murder cases. For example, it is hard to find
More...
Strange Company - 2/17/2020
Beginning on January 1st, W&W will begin featuring fascinating short clippings from the Fall River papers and other newspapers from …

Continue reading

More...
Lizzie Borden: Warps and Wefts - 12/29/2019
Every day since Halloween 2007, the blog ExecutedToday.com has posted a story of an execution that took place on that date in history somewhere in the world. While this certainly says something about the human condition over time, it also says something about the determination and thoroughness of the blogger of ExecutedToday.com, who goes by the epithet Headsman. As someone who has scrambled to
More...
Murder By Gaslight - 2/15/2020

Wherever rich New Yorkers built their homes in the 19th century, they also built private stables for their expensive horses and carriages—with upstairs living quarters for a coachman or groom. So when Upper Fifth Avenue along Central Park became the city’s new Millionaire Mile during the Gilded Age, certain Upper East Side blocks to the […]
More...
Ephemeral New York - 2/17/2020
[Editor’s note: Guest writer, Peter Dickson, lives in West Sussex, England and has been working with microfilm copies of The Duncan Campbell Papers from the State Library of NSW, Sydney, Australia. The following are some of his analyses of what he has discovered from reading these papers. Dickson has contributed many transcriptions to the Jamaica Family […]
More...
Early American Crime - 2/7/2019
Anxious For a Funeral | Trixie Got the Best of It.

Boss Cox.

Cincinnait-cox

For most of the nineteenth century, political power was a greased pig in Cincinnati, Ohio, chased by a multitude of neighborhood gangs, and seldom held long by anyone. But by the 1890s, though still wild, it was tightly sacked by “Boss” George B. Cox. In an age when every city in America was governed by some form of political machine, in Cincinnati Boss Cox had constructed a machine that was all but frictionless.[more]

George B Cox

Unlike New York’s Tammany Hall, which provided cover for graft at every level of city government, in the Cox machine all graft rose directly to the top, where it was distributed to those below according to a predetermined schedule.  Everyone who did business in Cincinnati - from constructing streetcar lines to sweeping the horse dung off the track - did so at the whim of George B. Cox. If you ran a bawdy house, or owned a saloon and wanted to sell drinks on Sunday or run games of chance upstairs, payment to the Cox machine was merely the cost of doing business.

The story of George Cox is a Horatio Alger tale gone awry. The orphaned son of English immigrants, Cox worked as a bootblack and a delivery boy. He also ran the keno game in his uncle’s saloon. While still in his twenties, he bought a saloon of his own at the corner of John and Hollingsworth streets, known as “dead man’s corner” for the number of murders that occurred there.

When Cox tried to run a faro game in his saloon, he was repeatedly shaken down by the police. Blaming the Democrats, who were then in power, Cox became a Republican, ran for city council and won. It would be his first and only elected office. What he learned in city council was that every deal that mattered was sealed outside the halls of government, and that no one’s word could be trusted. As Cincinnati struggled to emerge from a period of political chaos, George Cox rose to prominence by forging deals backed by his growing reputation as a man who never made a promise he did not keep. Boss Cox ruled Cincinnati from the outside by guaranteeing the election of candidates who would tend the machine without question.

By 1896, when the machine was fully polished, Boss Cox kept a sparse office above the Mecca Café, where he gave audiences to job seekers and dealmakers.  His work did not end when the sun went down. He went next to Weilert’s Beer Garden,Wielerts where he and his lieutenants sat at a round table, drinking beer from monogrammed mugs and discussing the state of affairs in the Queen City. This group, informally known as “the gang” or "the sports" includeed of August “Garry” Hermann and Rudolph “Rud” Hynicka. They would later be joined by Mike Mullen, a Democratic ward healer who had been instrumental in electing Cox’s protégé, John Caldwell, mayor in 1894.

August Hermann
August Hermann

Hermann, who gained the nickname Garry by his unfortunate resemblance to the Italian leader, Garibaldi, was the ultimate glad hander. After a meeting at Weilert’s, which could easily go past midnight, he was likely to have an appointment to entertain another favor seeker somewhere else around town. No matter what was done, no matter how much beer was drunk, no matter what time they all broke for home, Hermann would be back in his office by nine the following morning, ready to start all over again. An avid baseball fan, Garry Hermann was the de facto commissioner of baseball, before the job officially existed, and he is considered the father of the World Series.

Rudolph Hynicka
Rudolph Hynicka

Rud Hynicka’s interests were somewhat less wholesome. He ran a burlesque theater and was expanding his holdings to create an intercity circuit for the sexual entertainment of the day. Hynicka was also the Boss’s political man on the ground. He kept a file on voting habits that included a card for every eligible voter in Cincinnati. Hynicka also organized the bummers and floaters, the citizens-for-a-day, fresh off the river, who voted in proxy for those otherwise disenfranchised Cincinnatians who had died since the last election.

The newspapers hounded Cox and his machine, and average citizens were not pleased with the way the machine worked, but Cox held on to power despite numerous challenges from reform campaigns in both parties. Reform candidates faced trouble in Cincinnati because there were no active reform movements that did not also advocate tight regulation, if not outright prohibition, of alcohol. With a growing population of immigrants from hard-drinking cultures and an influx of American blue-collar workers, restriction of alcohol was not a winning platform. Under Boss Cox, even Sunday-closing laws, already on the books, were ignored.

Boss Cox suffered a stroke in February 1916 and died three months later. The machine struggled on for another decade before breaking down, unable to run smoothly without its engineer.

In spite of a driving rainstorm, Cox's funeral drew an enormous crowd--one of the largest in Cincinnati's history. The massive turnout at his funeral appeared to confirm Boss Cox’s often stated self-assessment, "A boss is not necessarily an enemy."


Sources:

  • Cincinnati Enquirer, Feb 28, 1897.
  • Miller, Zane L., Boss Cox’s Cincinnati Urban Politics in the Progressive Era. Westport, Conn:Greenwood P, 1981.
  • Police and Municipal Guide Cincinnati 1901. [Cincinnati], 1901.
  • Wright, Henry C. Bossism in Cincinnati. Cincinnati, 1905.
  • Wielerts Cafe